Reconciling International Climate Law and the Energy Charter Treaty through Integrative Interpretation in Arbitration
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35723/lsjs.v1i1.52Keywords:
Investment Arbitration, Energy Charter Treaty, Principle of Systemic Integration, International Climate LawAbstract
The Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) aims to protect energy investments, including fossil fuels, while international climate law seeks to mitigate climate change two objectives that can come into conflict in investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS). Given the unlikelihood of ECT modernization or termination in the near future, arbitration under the treaty will continue to shape the legal landscape of energy investments. This article explores the potential of integrative interpretation as a means to reconcile climate obligations with ECT protections in arbitration. Integrative interpretation is not only mandated by international treaty interpretation rules but is also reflected in the practice of international dispute settlement. However, despite this legal foundation, no ECT tribunal has yet incorporated international climate law into its decisions. While practical challenges and uncertainties persist, precedents from broader international dispute settlement and climate litigation suggest that ECT arbitration could evolve to balance investment protection with climate commitments. This article argues that fostering an integrative interpretative approach could enable ISDS to serve both investment stability and climate mitigation goals, contributing to a more coherent legal framework for energy transition.
References
[1] Berebon, C. (2023). Engagement of Children in Conflict Zones in Africa: Ethical Dilemma. Alkebulan: A Journal of West and East African Studies, 3(2), 41-54.
[2] Berebon, C. (2023a). Analysing the Russia-Ukraine Conflict from Liberal and Realist Perspectives. GNOSI: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Human Theory and Praxis, 6(2), 87-98.
[3] Berebon, C. (2023b). Ethical Perspectives of Digital Divide: An African Case Study. Multilingual African Digital Semiotics and E-lit Journal (MADSEJ), 1(1), 67-87.
[4] Berebon, C. (2024). Identity Conflicts In Nigeria: Historical Perspectives And Contemporary Implications. Tamaddun, 23(1), 177-189.
[5] Berebon, C. B. (2022). Existential approach towards religion. INSIGHT, 2(2).
[6] Bernasconi-Osterwalder, N., Schaugg, L., & Van den Berghe, A. (2021). Energy Charter Treaty reform: Why withdrawal is an option. ITN, 12, 16–20.
[7] Bos, K., & Gupta, J. (2019). Stranded assets and stranded resources: Implications for climate change mitigation and global sustainable development. Energy Research & Social Science, 56, 101215. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2019.101215
[8] Bundesnetzagentur. (2020). Ausschreibung nach dem KVBG/Gebotstermin 1. Retrieved December 12, 2023, from https://www.bundesnetzagentur.de/DE/Fachthemen/ElektrizitaetundGas/Kohleausstieg/BeendeteAusschreibungen/0109_2020/start.html
[9] Cima, E. (2021). Retooling the Energy Charter Treaty for climate change mitigation: Lessons from investment law and arbitration. World Energy Law and Business, 14, 75–87. https://doi.org/10.1093/welb/wbab004
[10] Climate Change Counsel. (2022). The Energy Charter Treaty, climate change, and clean energy transition: A study of the jurisprudence. Retrieved December 10, 2023, from https://www.climatechangecounsel.com/_files/ugd/f1e6f3_d184e02bff3d49ee8144328e6c45215f.pdf
[11] de Brabandere, E. (2019). Human rights and international investment law. In M. Krajewski, R. T. Hoffmann, & I. Alvik (Eds.), Research handbook on foreign direct investment (pp. 619–645). Edward Elgar Publishing.
[12] De Nanteuil, A. (2020). International investment law. Edward Elgar Publishing.
[13] Essien, M. M. (1992). Deep-level High tone as a relational link in certain Ibibio constructions. Journal of West African Languages, 22, 59-68.
[14] Essien, M. M. (1993). Language Development: the Ibibio experience. Teaching Nigerian Languages: experiences from the Delta. COEWA Publishers. Warri, 36-49.
[15] Federal Ministry for Economy and Climate Protection Germany. (2022). Eckpunktepapier „Weiterentwicklung des Eckpunktepapiers‚ Handelspolitik der Bundesregierung‘“. Retrieved December 15, 2023, from https://www.bmwk.de/Redaktion/DE/Downloads/E/eckpunktepapier-weiterentwicklung-des-eckpunktepapiers-handelspolitik-der-bundesregierung.pdf
[16] Giannopoulos, N. (2020). International law and offshore energy production: Marine environmental protection through normative interactions (Doctoral dissertation, Utrecht University).
[17] Haut Conseil pour le Climat. (2022). Report on the modernization of the Energy Charter Treaty. Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://www.hautconseilclimat.fr/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/2022-10-19-TCE_HCC_EN.pdf
[18] Hinrichsen, E. (2023). The Energy Charter Treaty and climate change: Reconciliation through integrative interpretation (Master’s thesis, University of Eastern Finland).
[19] Ignatius, I. P. (2022). Decay in Educational System: The Nigerian Perspective. Journal of Graduate Education Research, 3(1), 5.
[20] International Energy Agency. (2021). Net zero by 2050: A roadmap for the global energy sector. Retrieved August 12, 2023, from https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/deebef5d-0c34-4539-9d0c-10b13d840027/netZeroby2050-ARoadmapfortheGlobalEnergySector_CORR.pdf
[21] International Law Commission. (2006). Report of the Study Group of the International Law Commission, finalized by M. Koskenniemi, Fragmentation of international law: Difficulties arising from the diversification and expansion of international law. II(2) YBILC 179, DOCUMENT A/CN.4/L.682 and Add.1. Retrieved April 15, 2024, from https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/574810?v=pdf
[22] IPCC. (2022). Summary for policymakers. In P. R. Shukla, J. Skea, R. Slade, A. A. Khourdajie, R. van Diemen, D. McCollum, M. Pathak, S. Some, P. Vyas, & R. Fradera (Eds.), Climate change 2022: Mitigation of climate change. Contribution of Working Group III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press.
[23] Jones, N., Muñoz Cabré, M., Piggot, G., & Lazarus, M. (2021). Tapping the potential of NDCs and LT-LEDS to address fossil fuel production. SEI Working Paper. Stockholm Environment Institute.
[24] Kjos, H. E. (2013). Applicable law in investor-state arbitration: The interplay between national and international law. Oxford University Press.
[25] Klager, R. (2016). Revisiting treatment standards—Fair and equitable treatment in light of sustainable development. In S. Hindelang & M. Krajewski (Eds.), Shifting paradigms in international investment law. Oxford University Press.
[26] Levashova, Y. (2019). The right of states to regulate in international investment law: The search for balance between public interest and fair and equitable treatment. Kluwer Law International.
[27] Levashova, Y. (2023, July 21). Climate litigation and responsible business conduct in the Dutch District Court case RWE v. The Netherlands. Jus Mundi Blog. Retrieved from https://blog.jusmundi.com/climate-litigation-and-responsible-business-conduct-in-the-dutch-district-court-case-rwe-v-the-netherlands/
[28] Mayer, B. (2022). International law obligations on climate change mitigation. Oxford University Press.
[29] McLachlan, C. (2005). The principle of systemic integration and Article 31(3)(c) of the Vienna Convention. International & Comparative Law Quarterly, 54, 279–319.
[30] Merrills, J., & de Brabandere, E. (2022). Merrills’ international dispute settlement (7th ed.). Cambridge University Press.
[31] Monti, A., & Fermeglia, M. (2023, July 31–August 4). Evolving standards of investment protection in the ECT modernization: A new era of climate-related investor-state disputes? Paper presented at the IUCN Colloquium, Joensuu, Finland.
[32] Okon, M. M. (2003). Ibibio Women’s Satirical Songs: A Sociolinguistic Perspective. Topical issues in sociolinguistics the Nigerian perspective, 265-277.
[33] Okon, M. M., & Akpan, I. J. (2003). The changing role of language in gender disparity and cultural change. Topical Issues in Sociolinguistics: The Nigerian Perspective. Aba: NINLAN.
[34] Okon, M. M., & Noah, P. N. (2004). Translation of the Bible into the Ibibio language: experience of the translator. Jolan: Journal of the linguistic Association of Nigeria, (8), 2001-2004.
[35] Pauwelyn, J. (2003). Conflict of norms in public international law. Cambridge University Press.
[36] Sands, P. (1998). Treaty custom and the cross-fertilization of international law. Yale Human Rights and Development Law Journal, 1, 85–106.
[37] Simma, B. (2011). Foreign investment arbitration: A place for human rights? International & Comparative Law Quarterly, 60, 573–596.
[38] Tienhaara, K. (2018). Regulatory chill in a warming world: The threat to climate policy posed by investor-state dispute settlement. Transnational Environmental Law, 7, 229–250.
[39] Umotong, I. D. (2020). Ethnic politics in nation building: The African perspective. Ifiok: Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, 5(1), 1-13.
[40] Umotong, I. D. (2021). Humanism and Terrorism: An Epistemic Overview. The International Journal of Humanities & Social Studies, 9(5).
[41] Umotong, I., & Dennis, O. (2018). An Expository Analysis of Martin Heidegger’s Quest for The Meaning of Being. Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, 4(1).
[42] UNFCCC. (2022). Report of the Conference of the Parties serving as the meeting of the Parties to the Paris Agreement on its third session, Glasgow, 31 October–13 November 2021. Bonn: United Nations Climate Change.
[43] Viñuales, J. E. (2012a). Foreign investment and the environment in international law. Cambridge University Press.
